Beautiful case with 120mm intake/exhaust and lotsa room?
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Devonavar
Beautiful case with 120mm intake/exhaust and lotsa room?
I need the help of all you case junkies.
I need tips/images/model numbers for non-beige cases that fulfill the following criteria:
- ready or easy-to-made 120mm intake/exhaust fan holes
- lots of room (sorry, no mid-towers)
- must be made out of metal (for at least partial RFI shielding)
- sturdy (i.e. not the tinniest aluminum cases that bend when you look at them)
- drive bay door (preferably with space in the doors inner surface for damping material)
- aesthetic appeal (yes, this is personal, so you be the judge when you post)
Any takers?
regards,
Halcyon
I need tips/images/model numbers for non-beige cases that fulfill the following criteria:
- ready or easy-to-made 120mm intake/exhaust fan holes
- lots of room (sorry, no mid-towers)
- must be made out of metal (for at least partial RFI shielding)
- sturdy (i.e. not the tinniest aluminum cases that bend when you look at them)
- drive bay door (preferably with space in the doors inner surface for damping material)
- aesthetic appeal (yes, this is personal, so you be the judge when you post)
Any takers?
regards,
Halcyon
Re: Beautiful case with 120mm intake/exhaust and lotsa room?
Compucase LX-6A21, should be have lots of room although a midicase, 120mm fans, black and nice looking, cheap! (only 52 euros in finland.)
Try the Yeong Yang YY-5601. Good steel construction and a unique design. Plus then you can help me find one !
http://www.yeongyang.com/
http://www.yeongyang.com/
-
- *Lifetime Patron*
- Posts: 230
- Joined: Sat Oct 26, 2002 4:05 pm
- Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada
Tom's Hardware just did a review of cases:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/20030428/index.html
My favorite one was the Compucase CI-6619:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/2003 ... ew-23.html
It's fairly similar to the D8000/Compucase LX-6A19 featured here under the recommended section but:
1. Only the back has a 120mm fan. The front features 2 x 80mm.
2. 1mm thick (as opposed to .80mm) steel construction.
3. It has a "Thermally Advantaged Air Guide"
4. The PCB at the front of the case has Firewire/USB 2.0/Audio In/Out.
(the D8000 I just got from Coolcases.com does not have the Firewire on the front PCB).
Now I know you were looking at both a 120 mm front and rear fan, but this may be a superior setup. Right now there isn't a "definitive" or "reference" quiet 120mm fan, so up at front, where the noise is most obtrusive, it may be better/safer to have two 80mm Panaflow L1As (and this may provide more airflow than a undervolted 120mm fan anyway). I don't know what this "Thermally Advantaged Air Guide" is, but it could be a good thing. If it's a hole in the side of the case then probably that would be a bad thing for a Quiet PC though, so that potentiall could be the cases downfall. Still, it looks like it has potential that's for sure !!
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/20030428/index.html
My favorite one was the Compucase CI-6619:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/2003 ... ew-23.html
It's fairly similar to the D8000/Compucase LX-6A19 featured here under the recommended section but:
1. Only the back has a 120mm fan. The front features 2 x 80mm.
2. 1mm thick (as opposed to .80mm) steel construction.
3. It has a "Thermally Advantaged Air Guide"
4. The PCB at the front of the case has Firewire/USB 2.0/Audio In/Out.
(the D8000 I just got from Coolcases.com does not have the Firewire on the front PCB).
Now I know you were looking at both a 120 mm front and rear fan, but this may be a superior setup. Right now there isn't a "definitive" or "reference" quiet 120mm fan, so up at front, where the noise is most obtrusive, it may be better/safer to have two 80mm Panaflow L1As (and this may provide more airflow than a undervolted 120mm fan anyway). I don't know what this "Thermally Advantaged Air Guide" is, but it could be a good thing. If it's a hole in the side of the case then probably that would be a bad thing for a Quiet PC though, so that potentiall could be the cases downfall. Still, it looks like it has potential that's for sure !!
-
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue May 06, 2003 7:14 pm
Damn that's an ugly bezel. BTW the insides look suspiciously similiar to the Antec Sonata (another mid-tower, another PC designed for acoustics) shown hereobiwan wrote:Try the Yeong Yang YY-5601.
For example:
YY 5601
Antec Sonata
@Marc999 - I like the case that you said was your favorite. It looks nice (though bit small)
Thanks for the tips so far!
I looked at the Tom's round up now too and personally found ATCS-Tek MRO-18 (aka Cooler Master TAC-T01) interesting, except that it's impossible to fit 120mm fan in the back (and probably in the front too). The inside form factor looks almost identical to my Antec 1038, which can theoretically fit a 120mm in the rear panel for exhaust, but then the side panel won't close anymore (I've tried):
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/2003 ... g_1752.jpg
What I really want is the front door that is dampable. This can significantly reduce optical drive noise, if properly done. I've done this on my Antec 1038 and while optical drives are far from silent, they are very much subdued with the use of a closed front door (+ damping there). This pretty much rules out the Compucase LX-6A21 for me personally.
The Ahanix Landrover mentioned looks interesting (although perhaps not to my taste, but not bad):
http://www.amdzone.com/articleview.cfm?ArticleID=1262
It is missing front intake fan slots and the HD 2x80mm fans are mounted sideways blowing case air onto the hd spots:
http://www.ahanix.com/photo.asp?photo=landrover06
I'm not sure how much padding the front door can accomodate, but it badly needs it as it's merely a see through plastic mesh and won't block any sound in default form at all:
http://www.ahanix.com/photo.asp?photo=landrover07
I'm beginning to think I have too big demands on the case. It seems that a beautiful and sturdily constructed case with a front door and 120mm intake/exhaust is not yet on the market (?).
There is of course the Antec SLK3700 (and many variations of that), but I'm not yet sold on it's looks :)
So, the search continues...
cheers,
Halcyon
regards,
Halcyon
I looked at the Tom's round up now too and personally found ATCS-Tek MRO-18 (aka Cooler Master TAC-T01) interesting, except that it's impossible to fit 120mm fan in the back (and probably in the front too). The inside form factor looks almost identical to my Antec 1038, which can theoretically fit a 120mm in the rear panel for exhaust, but then the side panel won't close anymore (I've tried):
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/2003 ... g_1752.jpg
What I really want is the front door that is dampable. This can significantly reduce optical drive noise, if properly done. I've done this on my Antec 1038 and while optical drives are far from silent, they are very much subdued with the use of a closed front door (+ damping there). This pretty much rules out the Compucase LX-6A21 for me personally.
The Ahanix Landrover mentioned looks interesting (although perhaps not to my taste, but not bad):
http://www.amdzone.com/articleview.cfm?ArticleID=1262
It is missing front intake fan slots and the HD 2x80mm fans are mounted sideways blowing case air onto the hd spots:
http://www.ahanix.com/photo.asp?photo=landrover06
I'm not sure how much padding the front door can accomodate, but it badly needs it as it's merely a see through plastic mesh and won't block any sound in default form at all:
http://www.ahanix.com/photo.asp?photo=landrover07
I'm beginning to think I have too big demands on the case. It seems that a beautiful and sturdily constructed case with a front door and 120mm intake/exhaust is not yet on the market (?).
There is of course the Antec SLK3700 (and many variations of that), but I'm not yet sold on it's looks :)
So, the search continues...
cheers,
Halcyon
regards,
Halcyon
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
Dude!
You need a Chenbro Genie! This is a great case that fits your requirements to a "T". It's a well-proven server case that has great ventalation and lots of room, it's built like a tank AND it has a door. I was about ready to buy one when the SLK3700 came out. I went with the 3700 because I didn't need all the room of the Genie.
Check it out, homes!
You need a Chenbro Genie! This is a great case that fits your requirements to a "T". It's a well-proven server case that has great ventalation and lots of room, it's built like a tank AND it has a door. I was about ready to buy one when the SLK3700 came out. I went with the 3700 because I didn't need all the room of the Genie.
Check it out, homes!
-
- Patron of SPCR
- Posts: 350
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 11:14 am
Newegg.com has a killer sale on the Genies right now:
http://www.newegg.com/app/viewproduct.a ... henbro+104
$68 and $69 with only $10 shipping.
You can contact Chenbro and try to get a hold of the A9971(SR10405) front bezel for it. It has a door.
http://www.chenbro.com.tw/product/product.jsp?p=2&s=204
In my opinion, the only downfall to the Genie is the negative air pressure. Negative air pressure will fight the quiet PSU's. I've seen how negative air pressure can almost completely stop the airflow from the Fortron PSU w/ 120mm fan. I can only imagine what negative pressure would do to a PSU like the SilenX.
If you get it, I would add two 120mm's in front and possibly block up the rear 92mm hole (which kind of bites because it's so high). Or as minimum, I'd run the 2 front fans faster, and the rear fans slow. Otherwise the PSU will starve.
http://www.newegg.com/app/viewproduct.a ... henbro+104
$68 and $69 with only $10 shipping.
You can contact Chenbro and try to get a hold of the A9971(SR10405) front bezel for it. It has a door.
http://www.chenbro.com.tw/product/product.jsp?p=2&s=204
In my opinion, the only downfall to the Genie is the negative air pressure. Negative air pressure will fight the quiet PSU's. I've seen how negative air pressure can almost completely stop the airflow from the Fortron PSU w/ 120mm fan. I can only imagine what negative pressure would do to a PSU like the SilenX.
If you get it, I would add two 120mm's in front and possibly block up the rear 92mm hole (which kind of bites because it's so high). Or as minimum, I'd run the 2 front fans faster, and the rear fans slow. Otherwise the PSU will starve.
I can't seem to find this case anywhere, even on Compucase's USA website...can you enlighten me?marc999 wrote:Tom's Hardware just did a review of cases:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/20030428/index.html
My favorite one was the Compucase CI-6619:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/2003 ... ew-23.html
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
Dang, that's wierd...Newegg used to carry Compucase but they dropped the entire line.Tullphan wrote:I can't seem to find this case anywhere, even on Compucase's USA website...can you enlighten me?marc999 wrote:Tom's Hardware just did a review of cases:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/20030428/index.html
My favorite one was the Compucase CI-6619:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/howto/2003 ... ew-23.html
Well, Directron has this Compucase 6919 which is basically identical to the 6619 except that it uses the Antec SX10x0/Chieftec Dragon style of detachable 3.5" drive bays instead of the Antec SLK3700 style of drive bays found in the 6619. Otherwise it looks the same.
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
If you're refering to that Directron case I linked above, the site claims that the PSU is a "HEC". If so, that's actually a very high quality PSU. They were (and possibly still are) the OEM supplier for Antec's PSUs.Tullphan wrote:I assume the power supply that comes with that case isn't of the highest quality?
-
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2003 10:45 pm
- Location: North Billerica, MA, USA
- Contact:
I have and reccomend a server cube case, the AMS CK1100B available at servercase.com.I need tips/images/model numbers for non-beige cases that fulfill the following criteria:
2 x 120mm exhaust, 3 x 80mm intakes (w/ provision for up to 6 more 80mm intakes if you are into fans...) it would be a fairly straight forward mod to replace the 80mm intakes with one or two 120mm's.- ready or easy-to-made 120mm intake/exhaust fan holes
10 external 5.25's, one external 3.5", 4 internal 3.5" Extended ATX (12" x 13") mobo mounts on slideout mobo tray. PSU not included but has several optional ones available, including redundant units.- lots of room (sorry, no mid-towers)
Yup, heavy duty steel, w/ spring fingers on the side panels to ensure good metal / metal contact. I would say RFI shielding would be good to excellent, about only way to improve would need a purpose built enclosure.- must be made out of metal (for at least partial RFI shielding)
Yes, heavy duty steel case, feels very solid with little or no flex.- sturdy (i.e. not the tinniest aluminum cases that bend when you look at them)
3 section locking door w/ pretty good space underneath. Entire front bezel is also easily removed, and has room under it to pack more insulation in spaces not used for air intake or drives.- drive bay door (preferably with space in the doors inner surface for damping material)
I like it , however I'm not a bling-bling fan - this is a big black monolithic cube w/ minimal lights (other than 14 LED drive status panel), no windows, side blowholes, or other pimp-rig features. I feel this makes the case an excellent candidate for those wanting to build a silent box, or otherwise mod it their own way.- aesthetic appeal (yes, this is personal, so you be the judge when you post)
Gooserider
Ok...but is it quiet??Ralf Hutter wrote:If you're refering to that Directron case I linked above, the site claims that the PSU is a "HEC". If so, that's actually a very high quality PSU. They were (and possibly still are) the OEM supplier for Antec's PSUs.Tullphan wrote:I assume the power supply that comes with that case isn't of the highest quality?
Also, getting ready to bite on this case & was looking for a couple of 80mm fans for the front. Since one fan is directly in front of the hdd cage, would one want to mount one hdd in the cage directly about the hdd cage & one in the hdd cage for more airflow from the front, or is front airflow (intake) really an issue?
I was thinking about getting the blue coolermaster tlf-r82 fan for the front for looks, but wasn't sure about how quiet it was. Then I read this:
http://store.yahoo.com/directron/noise.html
I really don't understand how they're getting their results after reading the manufacturer specs on the fans.
Comments? Suggestions?
-
- Posts: 1283
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 1:35 am
- Location: Sweden, Linkoping
I guess this question doesn't really belong to this thread. It should go under the fans section. I guess the answer can be found there as well.Tullphan:
I really don't understand how they're getting their results after reading the manufacturer specs on the fans.
Comments? Suggestions?
They make a few conclusions. Fan noise in dBA for a specific fan is very close to proportional to the cfm rate.
What they don't mention is two important things.
1. Fan noise for good brand fans are lower than fan noise from bad brands at same cfm. (see fan section about what fans brands are good).
2. dB noise is a logarithmic scale, while cfm is a linear scale. This is why you get lower sound level when running two fans at half speed instead of one fan at full speed (total cfm value will be the same). This is why cases with lots of places for fans are considered "quieter". The case itself does not create any sound, but it might amplify or dampen sound to some degree.
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
No, but it doesn't have to be quiet to be high quality.Tullphan wrote:Ok...but is it quiet??Ralf Hutter wrote:If you're refering to that Directron case I linked above, the site claims that the PSU is a "HEC". If so, that's actually a very high quality PSU. They were (and possibly still are) the OEM supplier for Antec's PSUs.Tullphan wrote:I assume the power supply that comes with that case isn't of the highest quality?
That's a bµll§h¡† article. It's full of holes. We've raked it over the coals a few times. Here's one, and here's another. There's more too, IIRC.Tullphan wrote:Then I read this:
http://store.yahoo.com/directron/noise.html
I really don't understand how they're getting their results after reading the manufacturer specs on the fans.
Comments? Suggestions?