HDD enclosures / $175USD Smart Drive Classic Cooper any good
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
HDD enclosures / $175USD Smart Drive Classic Cooper any good
Rebuilding my system and am looking for ways to reduce disk noise. Currently using Scythe Quiet Drives, but can still hear the vibration noise and my tolerance for noise is low.
Is the "Smart Drive Classic Cooper" any good? I'm looking for results, so price is secondary to results, but for $175USD I want to be sure.
http://www.quietpcusa.com/Smart-Drive-C ... earCache=1
Haven't kept up with the latest in noise reduction techs, so am wondering if anyone has any other suggestions on the best way to reduce disk noise via enclosures?[/url]
Is the "Smart Drive Classic Cooper" any good? I'm looking for results, so price is secondary to results, but for $175USD I want to be sure.
http://www.quietpcusa.com/Smart-Drive-C ... earCache=1
Haven't kept up with the latest in noise reduction techs, so am wondering if anyone has any other suggestions on the best way to reduce disk noise via enclosures?[/url]
That's from back in 2002? If the new copper version that costs 3 times as much is the same, then forget it as vibration noise is what I'm trying to eliminate.jaganath wrote:reviewed here. if it really is only vibrational noise that is left, then try soft-mounting (ie either on foam or suspended).
I might just take some rubber bands and soft mount my drives.... but then non-vibrational noise may now become audible.
Has sound dampening technology improved since 2002? There's got to be a professional solution that's better than what we can do ourselves and that eliminates normal as well as vibrational noise. Is there?
-
- Posts: 1283
- Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 2:43 pm
- Location: Charlotte, NC, USA
While still a bit pricy (and it's still available elsewhere, I just didn't bother to check) the aluminum version is more than sufficient, at half the price: http://www.endpcnoise.com/cgi-bin/e/std ... e2002.html
Chances are the Scythe enclosures you already have are quieter.
I've had one of the cheaper aluminium Smart Drive 2002c enclosures for a few months now. The hard drive in it is a Samsung Spinpoint T HD401LJ 400gb SATA drive.
The drive sits on the internal copper plates inside which transfer heat out to the shell. My drive has thermal paste between the drive and the plates. Build quality is really high and it's nicely made. It's quite good for temperatures and is better than a bare drive for noise.
Don't expect anything like silence from it though.
It gets rid of some hard drive hum but doesn't do much about seek noise.
If you have it hard mounted to the case it's a racket.
Have you tried soft mounting or suspending your current hard drive enclosures? With your current aluminium Lian-Li PC-S80 case that would probably give you the most benefit.
I ended up placing my drive on foam so it doesn't touch the case. Even so it's only fairly quiet.
Smart Drive 2002C Drive Enclosure Mounted on Foam (Blanking Plate Removed)
I've had one of the cheaper aluminium Smart Drive 2002c enclosures for a few months now. The hard drive in it is a Samsung Spinpoint T HD401LJ 400gb SATA drive.
The drive sits on the internal copper plates inside which transfer heat out to the shell. My drive has thermal paste between the drive and the plates. Build quality is really high and it's nicely made. It's quite good for temperatures and is better than a bare drive for noise.
Don't expect anything like silence from it though.
It gets rid of some hard drive hum but doesn't do much about seek noise.
If you have it hard mounted to the case it's a racket.
Have you tried soft mounting or suspending your current hard drive enclosures? With your current aluminium Lian-Li PC-S80 case that would probably give you the most benefit.
I ended up placing my drive on foam so it doesn't touch the case. Even so it's only fairly quiet.
Smart Drive 2002C Drive Enclosure Mounted on Foam (Blanking Plate Removed)
-
- Posts: 1386
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 6:53 pm
I got Scythe Quiet Drives, and they still do not completely mask idle HDD sound. You'd think they would make drive almost inaudible, and yet I can still hear it if I put my ear within 1-2 feet from it.WR304 wrote:I ended up placing my drive on foam so it doesn't touch the case. Even so it's only fairly quiet.
They do definitely help to quiet the drive, but it's hard to say objectively by how much. I think that they help noisier drives much more than already quiet ones. I've got 3-platter seagates in Quiet Drive and Samsung HD321KJ and I think it helps seagates a lot more than it does samsung.
I've definitely had more success just replacing the hard drives with new ones for reducing noise.
My Samsung Spinpoint T hard drive is quite a bit quieter than the Western Digital hard drives it replaced. It's still a 3.5" hard drive and clearly audible with or without enclosures/suspension etc though.
The problem of all these retail hard drive enclosures is that they're designed to fit in a 5.25" bay. The hard drive really needs to be buried in a larger enclosure for more effect. That way you're not as limited in how much damping material surrounds the drive.
A laptop hard drive or one of the new solid state drives would probably go a long way towards reducing hard drive noise.
Solid State Drives look like they'll be a reasonable option soon. £300 to get the PC a bit quieter isn't too bad really...
http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2007/0 ... te_drive/1
64 gig SSD drives should be available soon also:
http://www.mydigitallife.info/2007/06/2 ... roduction/
Additional storage could be provided by a NAS box such as one of these Qnap TS-109 Pro NAS boxes in a different room:
http://www.hexus.net/content/item.php?item=9344&page=1
http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/hardware ... eview.html
It's passively cooled, has built in gigabit ethernet and running Linux you have a wide range of configuration options.
That's the way I'm starting to look at going anyway.
My Samsung Spinpoint T hard drive is quite a bit quieter than the Western Digital hard drives it replaced. It's still a 3.5" hard drive and clearly audible with or without enclosures/suspension etc though.
The problem of all these retail hard drive enclosures is that they're designed to fit in a 5.25" bay. The hard drive really needs to be buried in a larger enclosure for more effect. That way you're not as limited in how much damping material surrounds the drive.
A laptop hard drive or one of the new solid state drives would probably go a long way towards reducing hard drive noise.
Solid State Drives look like they'll be a reasonable option soon. £300 to get the PC a bit quieter isn't too bad really...
http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2007/0 ... te_drive/1
64 gig SSD drives should be available soon also:
http://www.mydigitallife.info/2007/06/2 ... roduction/
Additional storage could be provided by a NAS box such as one of these Qnap TS-109 Pro NAS boxes in a different room:
http://www.hexus.net/content/item.php?item=9344&page=1
http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/hardware ... eview.html
It's passively cooled, has built in gigabit ethernet and running Linux you have a wide range of configuration options.
That's the way I'm starting to look at going anyway.
-
- Posts: 1386
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 6:53 pm
I don't think they will be a reasonable option soon. I'd rather buy 2.5" drive and new Scythe 2.5" enclosure, inside the case combination of two should be completely inaudible. Same effect, but only $100-120 out of pocket.WR304 wrote:Solid State Drives look like they'll be a reasonable option soon. £300 to get the PC a bit quieter isn't too bad really...
-
- Posts: 1283
- Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 2:43 pm
- Location: Charlotte, NC, USA
What alleycat said. I've got the relevant links in the hard drive enclosure in this FAQ in the newcomer room: viewtopic.php?t=21152
-
- Posts: 1386
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 6:53 pm
The enclosure does not "generate" condensation, which is basically impossible. Where did you read about this? I'd be interested to know the physics behind such a phenomenon. I love how pervasive a little FUD is; it's an interesting insight into human nature, but that's getting WAY off topic.
You may "seriously doubt it completely silences" the drive, and I have never claimed that it does. What it does do, and has been doing for nearly three years, is render the drive inaudible from any practical distance. Just for you, I yet again opened my PC and put my ear about 5cm from the enclosure. There is a feint hum, quieter than the undervolted Nexus fan on the back of my case. I can't tell when the drive is seeking; I need to look at the light on the front panel.
A few others around these forums have constructed the enclosure with similar results. You too are welcome to try; perhaps then you could make some useful comments.
You may "seriously doubt it completely silences" the drive, and I have never claimed that it does. What it does do, and has been doing for nearly three years, is render the drive inaudible from any practical distance. Just for you, I yet again opened my PC and put my ear about 5cm from the enclosure. There is a feint hum, quieter than the undervolted Nexus fan on the back of my case. I can't tell when the drive is seeking; I need to look at the light on the front panel.
A few others around these forums have constructed the enclosure with similar results. You too are welcome to try; perhaps then you could make some useful comments.
You can add the QuietDrive 3.5" on the 2.5" with a Spinpoint M(22-26 dB).JazzJackRabbit wrote:I'd rather buy 2.5" drive and new Scythe 2.5" enclosure, inside the case combination of two should be completely inaudible. Same effect, but only $100-120 out of pocket.
But a Spinpoint S(24-28 dB) would be cheaper.
total hogwash, 1 and 2. Allycats enclosure WORKS, and works freakin well.JazzJackRabbit wrote:1. From what I've read alleycat's enclosure is prone to generate condensation inside.
2. I seriously doubt it completely silences the drive. It might be as good or better than commercially available HDD enclosures, but it will not be silent.
Ok, if the best solutions provided by manufacturers are mediocre amateurish solutions 5 years old, then I suppose have to improvise like everyone else.
I've decoupled my Scythe Quiet Drives from the standard mountings and have them sandwiched between layers of acouti foam. Pressure from the foam holds the SQD in place. Looks terrible compared to a professionally manufactured solution but it is very effective. I'll probably end up taping the foam to the SQD to make it look a bit more sturdy, but it works. No more vibration sound. In fact, no more HDD sound. Peace and quiet.
Was initially apprehensive of the static from the foam shorting out the HDD's or heat causing it to burn, or the HDD's heating up too much as they're wrapped in a SQD and foam, but so far no problems.
And it's quiet which is the only important thing.
I've decoupled my Scythe Quiet Drives from the standard mountings and have them sandwiched between layers of acouti foam. Pressure from the foam holds the SQD in place. Looks terrible compared to a professionally manufactured solution but it is very effective. I'll probably end up taping the foam to the SQD to make it look a bit more sturdy, but it works. No more vibration sound. In fact, no more HDD sound. Peace and quiet.
Was initially apprehensive of the static from the foam shorting out the HDD's or heat causing it to burn, or the HDD's heating up too much as they're wrapped in a SQD and foam, but so far no problems.
And it's quiet which is the only important thing.