Low(ish) profile Passive Heatsink for an HTPC
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
Low(ish) profile Passive Heatsink for an HTPC
I guess the Subject is a bit of a contradiction in terms, so i'm not necessarily expecting a good answer, but hey, you never know.
I'm looking to turn a PC i'm about to replace into and HTPC, and I'd like to passively cool the processor. It's a celeron 2 GHz system (Northwood), and I'm wondering which heatsinks i'm going to be able to use. At the moment the most likely case options are the Silverstone LC17, Antec NSK2400 or nMedia PC HTPC200, all of which are roughly 3U in height.
I'm assuming that rules me out of using the Scythe Ninja Cooler, or does it?
What about the Thermalright XP-120? Can that be used without a fan, or are the fins too close together.
I'm also concerned that a cooler with a specifc direction of flow like the XP-120 might not work so well passively the antec case where the air has to turn 90 degrees to leave the case.
Any ideas on this?
Thanks,
Sandy Scott
I'm looking to turn a PC i'm about to replace into and HTPC, and I'd like to passively cool the processor. It's a celeron 2 GHz system (Northwood), and I'm wondering which heatsinks i'm going to be able to use. At the moment the most likely case options are the Silverstone LC17, Antec NSK2400 or nMedia PC HTPC200, all of which are roughly 3U in height.
I'm assuming that rules me out of using the Scythe Ninja Cooler, or does it?
What about the Thermalright XP-120? Can that be used without a fan, or are the fins too close together.
I'm also concerned that a cooler with a specifc direction of flow like the XP-120 might not work so well passively the antec case where the air has to turn 90 degrees to leave the case.
Any ideas on this?
Thanks,
Sandy Scott
I'm doing much the same as you at the moment so I can highly recommend the XP (or SI) 120. I've done a fair bit of checking around and can tell you for sure that the nija won't fit in either the nsk2400 or the lc17. The XP120 can fit in both (depending on CPU placement).
Good luck with the search.
Garmpe
Good luck with the search.
Garmpe
Well, I actually agree with you. Linguistically, I really hate it that people call a heatsink "passive" when in fact there is some forced airflow across/through it. Unfortunately, the common usage for "passive heatsink" simply means the heatsink doesn't have a fan mounted directly on it or ducted to it.
To me, it's not "truly passive" unless either the entire system is truly passive or the particular heatsink is well outside the main airflow paths. But what's the point of using language in a way which contradicts the accepted common usage?
In this example, the XP-120 in question won't be "truly passive", due to the nearby case fan(s). Indeed, the short height of an HTPC case could almost act like a crude duct encouraging a larger fraction of the airflow to pass along the heatsink fins.
To me, it's not "truly passive" unless either the entire system is truly passive or the particular heatsink is well outside the main airflow paths. But what's the point of using language in a way which contradicts the accepted common usage?
In this example, the XP-120 in question won't be "truly passive", due to the nearby case fan(s). Indeed, the short height of an HTPC case could almost act like a crude duct encouraging a larger fraction of the airflow to pass along the heatsink fins.
I only used "passive" in the confined sense of the CPU cooler, which I think is justified, as the intention is to cool the cpu without the extra fan, and hopefully not need the case fans to do much more work.
But you guess what I meant, so it's alright really
I reckon I'm going to get the XP-120 and a 120mm fan anyway, before I do the upgrade and get the benefits now (still got the stock cooler - it's probably 3-4 times louder than anything else in the case) and when I get the new case I'll do a few experiments and see if the cpu fan is needed.
But you guess what I meant, so it's alright really
I reckon I'm going to get the XP-120 and a 120mm fan anyway, before I do the upgrade and get the benefits now (still got the stock cooler - it's probably 3-4 times louder than anything else in the case) and when I get the new case I'll do a few experiments and see if the cpu fan is needed.
Re: Low(ish) profile Passive Heatsink for an HTPC
What's a U? I generally think in terms of milli-meters and inches.sando wrote: ...all of which are roughly 3U in height.
Re: Low(ish) profile Passive Heatsink for an HTPC
1U, 2U, 3U, etc are all rackmount speak (can also be called 1RU (1 rack unit) etc). Conversion wise, 1U is 44mm or 1.75".stupid wrote:What's a U? I generally think in terms of milli-meters and inches.
A 1U heatsink is not actually 44mm tall though, they are roughly 25mm tall to accomodate the motherboard, CPU and enclosure thicknesses.