Best 5TB Hard Drives

Our top picks for the best 5TB hard drives

Silent PC Review is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More

Table of Contents

Running out of storage space is a common issue these days, but fear not, as 5TB hard drives offer a solution. They come in various flavors, catering to different needs. Some are geared toward gamers seeking top-notch performance, while others target streamers and content creators who require ample space to store their recordings without constant backups.

Furthermore, many of these drives feature adaptive packaging, simplifying installation. This ensures you can spend more time enjoying your computer and less time fiddling with components. Whether you’re upgrading your home office PC or enhancing your streaming setup, there’s a 5TB hard drive on this list for you.

From straightforward hard drives for everyday use to robust options, we present our top picks for the best 5TB hard drives.

Best Overall Hard Drive: Seagate Barracuda 5TB

Seagate Barracuda 5TB

Seagate BarraCuda 5TB

Digital Storage Capacity

5 TB

Connectivity Technology


Special Feature

Hot Plug Support, SMART

  • Exceptional value for the price
  • Offers a wide range of storage options
  • Had reliability concerns in the past
  • May have lower random read/write speeds

If you’re looking to save money without compromising on performance, the Seagate BarraCuda is an excellent choice. It offers outstanding value for your budget, making it a cost-effective storage solution. 

Despite its affordability, the regular BarraCuda shares many features with its Pro counterpart, including a 7200 RPM rotational speed, SATA 6Gb/s support, and a range of storage capacities.

In recent years, reports suggest that the reliability of this drive has significantly improved. However, it’s worth noting that the BarraCuda may not excel in random read/write speeds, which are important for real-world usage.

Runner-Up: WD Black 5TB

WD Black 5TB

Hard Disk Interface

USB 3.0

Special Feature


Hard Disk Form Factor

2.5 Inches

  • Excellent value for the price
  • Highly reliable
  • Backed by a 5-year warranty
  • Can be a bit noisy
  • Not as fast as the FireCuda

Western Digital’s top-tier HDD line, the Black series, might not be the absolute fastest performer, trailing behind the likes of the FireCuda and WD VelociRaptor. However, they have a solid reputation for reliability and dependability. These drives excel in game storage, especially for titles that don’t require lightning-fast load times, such as single-player games.

In a world where the FireCuda SSHD isn’t an option, the WD Black would easily be our top pick, thanks to its consistent performance, trustworthiness, and reasonable price point. Although it’s a bit pricier than its Blue counterpart, which we’ll discuss shortly, the Black series strikes an excellent balance between performance and value.

Western Digital has streamlined its HDD lineup by dropping the “Caviar” branding and adopting straightforward color-based names. These drives come in capacities ranging from a modest 500GB to a substantial 6TB, catering to a wide range of budgets. And if you’re looking for one in 5TB, then you can pick one up right now.

Best Portable Hard Drive: WD My Passport 5TB

WD My Passport 5TB

Connectivity Technology


Special Feature

Data Recovery Service

Digital Storage Capacity

5 TB

  • Excellent cost per gigabyte
  • Appealing design
  • Comprehensive software package
  • Slower than average for large files

WD’s My Passport 5TB mobile USB 3.0 drive allows you to carry a substantial amount of data without breaking the bank. While it might not match the sequential transfer speeds of competitors like LaCie and Seagate, it delivers sufficient performance. Plus, it comes at a wallet-friendly price of $115.

Due to the 15mm thick 5TB drive inside, the My Passport 5TB isn’t as slim as some lower-capacity alternatives, measuring 0.85 inches in height. It’s approximately 4.25 inches long, 3.1 inches wide, and weighs around 8 ounces. 

The My Passport is available in various colors, ranging from classic black to vibrant white, red, orange, blue, and yellow. While it may not match the Seagate Backup Plus Fast or the Samsung T3 in terms of rapid data transfer for large amounts of data, it excels at handling small files and everyday copying tasks. Additionally, it comes at an attractive price point, especially if you can find it below the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP).

In Summary

That pretty much wraps up our top picks for the best 5TB hard drives on the market without breaking the bank!

About the Author