HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
If I were to add nylon clips or P clips on the bottom of the drive (both front and back) and have holes on both sides of the 5.35 cage, could I just use nylon cords, one on each side to tie them down? Seems like it wouldn't transfer the vibration, the clips will keep them from sliding backwards or forwards and also the tension from the right and left side should keep them from sliding from left to right.
I currently have a WD5000AAKS drive hard mounted in the standard drive cage of my Silverstone LC17 cabinet. This causes some vibration hum when the computer is put in my hifi rack, but not much hum when the computer is put on a normal table.
Almost all of the vibration hum is eliminated if I place the computer on some soft material, e.g. packing material for sensitive electronics. I plan to make it look a bit nicer by mounting the packing material permanently under a piece of wood that I will let the computer rest on.
Maybe this is not enough the take away vibration hum from any kind of computer cabinet but it works surprisingly well on my Silverstone cabinet. I guess the cabinet itself is so rigid that it will not vibrate much. It also works quite well on some Lenovo SFF desktops we have at work.
Cirkus
Almost all of the vibration hum is eliminated if I place the computer on some soft material, e.g. packing material for sensitive electronics. I plan to make it look a bit nicer by mounting the packing material permanently under a piece of wood that I will let the computer rest on.
Maybe this is not enough the take away vibration hum from any kind of computer cabinet but it works surprisingly well on my Silverstone cabinet. I guess the cabinet itself is so rigid that it will not vibrate much. It also works quite well on some Lenovo SFF desktops we have at work.
Cirkus
Hi,
my 2 cents on this sticky : if you use the grommets on the HD trays in the Solo case, I've noticed they do a better job in reducing vibrations if you put the tray upside down (that would be with the HD's PCB pointing up). You end up with the HD suspended.. in a way...
my 2 cents on this sticky : if you use the grommets on the HD trays in the Solo case, I've noticed they do a better job in reducing vibrations if you put the tray upside down (that would be with the HD's PCB pointing up). You end up with the HD suspended.. in a way...
Last edited by frenchie on Wed Sep 10, 2008 8:15 am, edited 1 time in total.
I just installed my HDD inside a Xilence HD Cooler CL...
A little disappointed by the noise reduction, or lack of it, to be honest, but it certainly keeps it cool. 6 or 7 degrees C lower than before (now at 33 C). Mind you it was elastically suspended before, so I might try elastically suspending the whole thing as well and see how that does. It's a little narrower than a 5 1/4 inch bay and the mounting grommets are removable, so it might be possible to suspend it where it is.
A little disappointed by the noise reduction, or lack of it, to be honest, but it certainly keeps it cool. 6 or 7 degrees C lower than before (now at 33 C). Mind you it was elastically suspended before, so I might try elastically suspending the whole thing as well and see how that does. It's a little narrower than a 5 1/4 inch bay and the mounting grommets are removable, so it might be possible to suspend it where it is.
..this is my home made solution.. a combination of half-close enclosure and anti vibration stuff... using the material shown aside the enclosure..
After this solution I cannot hear any sound at all from the HDD.. neither on seek, idle or vibrations.
http://peecee.dk/upload/view/159900
http://peecee.dk/upload/view/159900/full
Regards
After this solution I cannot hear any sound at all from the HDD.. neither on seek, idle or vibrations.
http://peecee.dk/upload/view/159900
http://peecee.dk/upload/view/159900/full
Regards
-
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2009 5:35 am
- Location: Belgium
In my old case, I used elastic suspension. I switched to an Antec P183 since, and the silicone grommets in the HDD bays are almost as good as elastic suspension. They dampen vibration almost completely (though this ability may be amplified by other attributes of the case).
Suspension was quieter, but only by VERY LITTLE. And I can't even tell for sure as when I switched cases, I added a new HD as well (WD Green 1.5tb). So the extra noise may be caused by the extra HD, and not the lack of suspension.
But, it's quiet enough so I can sleep with my system going at night (about 2 meters from my bed).
Suspension was quieter, but only by VERY LITTLE. And I can't even tell for sure as when I switched cases, I added a new HD as well (WD Green 1.5tb). So the extra noise may be caused by the extra HD, and not the lack of suspension.
But, it's quiet enough so I can sleep with my system going at night (about 2 meters from my bed).
-
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sat Feb 20, 2010 2:50 am
- Location: London
I've had a number of cases, and neither the provided mounting or any modification I made could remove all of the HD vibrations. So, I decided to take a more radical approach:
Coolermaster Stacker 4in3 module placed inside an old subwoofer box lined with acoustic foam, cooled by a 22cm akasa fan running @ 5v, connected to the PC via an extended molex + 100cm sata cables.
HD temps are 5-7c above ambient with no vibrations and very quiet (not silent as they are Samsung F3s).
Full size images:
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... ru/top.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... u/back.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... /front.jpg
I know, the fan need a good clean
Coolermaster Stacker 4in3 module placed inside an old subwoofer box lined with acoustic foam, cooled by a 22cm akasa fan running @ 5v, connected to the PC via an extended molex + 100cm sata cables.
HD temps are 5-7c above ambient with no vibrations and very quiet (not silent as they are Samsung F3s).
Full size images:
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... ru/top.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... u/back.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... /front.jpg
I know, the fan need a good clean
For those of you concerned with drive temperatures you should read this:
http://www.google.com/search?q=google+h ... =firefox-a
Click on the PDF. See figure 4.1
Don't worry too much about drive temperatures. Also read the conclusions. If your drive gives you an error prepare to replace it.
http://www.google.com/search?q=google+h ... =firefox-a
Click on the PDF. See figure 4.1
Don't worry too much about drive temperatures. Also read the conclusions. If your drive gives you an error prepare to replace it.
I call him Bub wrote:I've had a number of cases, and neither the provided mounting or any modification I made could remove all of the HD vibrations. So, I decided to take a more radical approach:
Coolermaster Stacker 4in3 module placed inside an old subwoofer box lined with acoustic foam, cooled by a 22cm akasa fan running @ 5v, connected to the PC via an extended molex + 100cm sata cables.
HD temps are 5-7c above ambient with no vibrations and very quiet (not silent as they are Samsung F3s).
Full size images:
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... ru/top.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... u/back.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo32 ... /front.jpg
I know, the fan need a good clean
How's that working for you. I have an 8 drive home server which will become a 16 drive home server very soon and I've realized this approach is the only way. I will put the whole thing inside a kitchen cabinet as well. Does it get rid of all HDD spinning noises?
I just came across this new "spring mounting" pattern for hard drives which supposedly "kills vibration"...
What's your take on it?
http://www.rwlabs.com/article.php?cat=& ... genumber=6
What's your take on it?
http://www.rwlabs.com/article.php?cat=& ... genumber=6
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
Does anyone have any recommendations for the kind of soft foam I should use to lay my HDD on in the bottom of my case?
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
Try a piece of the thin light open-cell foam which protects motherboards from shock in their boxes. If this is too thin, try two layers -- maybe fold one over. Putting the HDD on it upside down may help w/ cooling -- the heavier cast aluminum on the bottom dissipates more heat than the thin steel top cover.Compddd wrote:Does anyone have any recommendations for the kind of soft foam I should use to lay my HDD on in the bottom of my case?
-
- Posts: 7
- Joined: Wed Dec 15, 2010 5:12 am
- Location: Chișinău, Moldova
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
Just flipped mine upside down and it got cooler by ~1°C at idle and 4°C (from 40°C to 36°C) after an hour of constant sequential activity. Not bad for a "free" method. Thanks.MikeC wrote:Putting the HDD on it upside down may help w/ cooling -- the heavier cast aluminum on the bottom dissipates more heat than the thin steel top cover.
P.S. Thta's a single-patter EcoGreen 503HI sitting on a piece of foam in the bottom of the case.
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
Need opinions on the Sharkoon Vibe Fixer.
Considering it looks exactly like a NoVibes, can one assume it's as good?
Considering it looks exactly like a NoVibes, can one assume it's as good?
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
yesrpsgc wrote:Need opinions on the Sharkoon Vibe Fixer.
Considering it looks exactly like a NoVibes, can one assume it's as good?
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
look into isolating the hard drive (aka shock-mounting it). This will reduce the amount of vibration transferred to the case.
I second that.Try these SilenX Hard Drive Grommets
I second that.Try these SilenX Hard Drive Grommets
Last edited by jafflen on Fri Jun 15, 2012 4:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
After having swapped my OS HDD with an SSD, I can clearly hear the annoying noise coming from my HD503HI storage disk.MikeC wrote: Eh - Plastic screwless rails as used in some cases
I've always wondered what if my Thermaltake V9000A plastic rails had foam stripes on their external sides. I guess that the vibrations transmitted to the case would be dumped.
-
- Posts: 346
- Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 1:42 am
- Location: Australia
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
Old question, but for the benefit of anyone reading this thread... In my experience:rpsgc wrote:When using sewing elastic (something like this) should the elastic be tight or somewhat loose? Could a very tight elastic suspension transmit vibrations?
Tight elastic or sewing cord: A tiny bit of vibration is transmitted, but it's still far better than direct metal-to-metal contact.
Loose elastic or sewing cord: Virtually no vibration is transmitted to the chassis.
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
I don't understand some of you guys running your disks without silencing enclosures and yet wondering how to make the drives less noisy with spring mounting Its the first thing to do to put the disk in the best silencing enclosure you can find and than care about mounting or whatever.
I am also curious why some of you cool those disks at all - are you getting temperature over 60 degrees celsius without a fan?
Depends on the usage but unless you run some database with disks heavily active in raid i would say hard drives can be idle most of the time and stay pretty cool even in silencing enclosures and without a fans.
If you don't have an SSD, buy one now.
The only thing that bothers me is the lack of RAID/JBOD enclosures with 5.25" bays to be loaded with hdds in enclosures.
From my personal experience with one enclosure, the difference in noise level is night and day between the bare drive and silenced one. And when you put that into properly dampened external box, its can be made almost silent!
I am also curious why some of you cool those disks at all - are you getting temperature over 60 degrees celsius without a fan?
Depends on the usage but unless you run some database with disks heavily active in raid i would say hard drives can be idle most of the time and stay pretty cool even in silencing enclosures and without a fans.
If you don't have an SSD, buy one now.
The only thing that bothers me is the lack of RAID/JBOD enclosures with 5.25" bays to be loaded with hdds in enclosures.
From my personal experience with one enclosure, the difference in noise level is night and day between the bare drive and silenced one. And when you put that into properly dampened external box, its can be made almost silent!
Re: HDD vibration & noise reducing methods - ranked
I know it's a very late answer. I currently use the exact same version of the Sharkoon VibeFixer as shown in the link on an ancient WD Green 500 GB. And I can confirm that it eliminates all vibration-induced noise.rpsgc wrote:Need opinions on the Sharkoon Vibe Fixer.
Considering it looks exactly like a NoVibes, can one assume it's as good?
Re:
My theory on this paper is that temperature swings are more responsible for HDD failure than average temperatures.sxr71 wrote:For those of you concerned with drive temperatures you should read this:
http://www.google.com/search?q=google+h ... =firefox-a
Click on the PDF. See figure 4.1
Don't worry too much about drive temperatures. Also read the conclusions. If your drive gives you an error prepare to replace it.
I don't want my NAS box to have hard drive failure, run hot or make noise so I filled it with WD red drives which test out as about the coolest running HDDs you can get so I decided to cool them by locating them directly behind my case intake fan.
That seems to go against the data in the Google paper but since the operating temps are so close to ambient, I figure a constant breeze will reduce the amplitude of the swings down to just a few degrees which is close enough to zero that neither absolute temperature nor temperature swings will contribute to hard drive failure.
So far, so good but it will take a few years before I can become a single data point.