Another SPCR recommended list: Cases
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
Another SPCR recommended list: Cases
Another SPCR recommended list: Cases.A few models recommended on the basis of reviews or first-hand experience; a few more that look promising for a number of reasons. The usual justifications for the choices, and a modus operandi about silent cool cases.
So tell me which cases you want to see on the list and why.
EDIT, 7 April 2010: Pretty much completely revised & updated -- http://www.silentpcreview.com/Case_Basi ... mendations
EDIT, 13 Feb 2012: Some recommendation changes based on reviews over the past year, some minor enhancements in the text.
EDIT, 28 Sept 2014: Complete overhaul.
So tell me which cases you want to see on the list and why.
EDIT, 7 April 2010: Pretty much completely revised & updated -- http://www.silentpcreview.com/Case_Basi ... mendations
EDIT, 13 Feb 2012: Some recommendation changes based on reviews over the past year, some minor enhancements in the text.
EDIT, 28 Sept 2014: Complete overhaul.
Last edited by MikeC on Wed Apr 07, 2010 10:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
Good review.
The Evercase 4252 is available from Newegg for $21(!) w/o a PSU. What a great place to start a quiet system from. Add the quiet PSU of your choice and away you go.
The Evercase 4252 is available from Newegg for $21(!) w/o a PSU. What a great place to start a quiet system from. Add the quiet PSU of your choice and away you go.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 7681
- Joined: Mon Dec 09, 2002 7:11 pm
- Location: Maynard, MA, Eaarth
- Contact:
New Egg is all out of stock on the black models.. :-(
Hello:
The price certainly makes them *very* attractive! However, New Egg is currently totally sold out of *all* the black versions! That must tell you something...what do the addtional letters in the model number mean? Some units seem to only have USB front ports, while others add audio and some also have Firewire.
One other positive point that was pointed out to me by someone who has built 3-4 systems with these: the motherboard supports are pressed into the case, and they are nice smooth domes. Very little chance of damaging the back of the mobo, and very easy!
If only it had 120mm fans and looked a little better...
The price certainly makes them *very* attractive! However, New Egg is currently totally sold out of *all* the black versions! That must tell you something...what do the addtional letters in the model number mean? Some units seem to only have USB front ports, while others add audio and some also have Firewire.
One other positive point that was pointed out to me by someone who has built 3-4 systems with these: the motherboard supports are pressed into the case, and they are nice smooth domes. Very little chance of damaging the back of the mobo, and very easy!
If only it had 120mm fans and looked a little better...
The only one I would touch would be the Lian-Li 6070. At least it has a vent at the bottom front, and a door to enclose the drives.
It would be really nice if Lian-Li sent a review sample to someone who really understands what quiet is supposed to be.
If it comes out good, I may even be willing to sacrifice my ATC-110.
It would be really nice if Lian-Li sent a review sample to someone who really understands what quiet is supposed to be.
If it comes out good, I may even be willing to sacrifice my ATC-110.
Re: Another SPCR recommended list: Cases
SuperFlower SF-201. Basically a Lian-Li with some extra fan holes (2 front, 2 rear, one side and one top).MikeC wrote:Another SPCR recommended list: Cases.A few models recommended on the basis of reviews or first-hand experience; a few more that look promising for a number of reasons. The usual justifications for the choices, and a modus operandi about silent cool cases.
So tell me which cases you want to see on the list and why.
I've just recently bought one and fitted it out with the AcoustiPack Deluxe foam, 6 x 12 dBa fans and a Zalman Flower cooler. No measurement of the noise I'm afraid, all I can say is that I can't hear it over my existing PC, even when I've got my head next to the case.
-
- -- Vendor --
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Sun May 23, 2004 12:01 pm
- Location: oregon
- Contact:
lian li 6070
i have a couple of these cases - they are quite a bit quieter than a regular case, and have great quality and detail.
by only complaints: horribly air-restricting fan grate on the back. i cut it out and put a wire grill, and it made quite a difference with a low-airflow fan.
and it's huge! deeper than my desks will hold. a bit overkill for most systems.
luck,
jef
by only complaints: horribly air-restricting fan grate on the back. i cut it out and put a wire grill, and it made quite a difference with a low-airflow fan.
and it's huge! deeper than my desks will hold. a bit overkill for most systems.
luck,
jef
-
- SPCR Reviewer
- Posts: 8636
- Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2002 6:33 am
- Location: Sunny SoCal
Since the sticky thread in the Cases Forum is locked, I'll post my 2¢ worth in this thread:
Mike - very nice work on the update and it's a great idea to post it as a sticky at the top of the "Cases" forum.
Now all we have to do is actually get people to read it before they post a "what's the best case" question.
Mike - very nice work on the update and it's a great idea to post it as a sticky at the top of the "Cases" forum.
Now all we have to do is actually get people to read it before they post a "what's the best case" question.
Super Flower SF-201 is a debatable recommendation. I'm currently using one now. Mine is the Terminator version so it has come with 3 perspex panels.
Good points:
Excellent case fans supplied. They need undervolting, but equal Real Silent Nexus case fans.
Seems to have the potential for good ventilation if fan grills removed.
Perpex panels are well integrated with the case
Comes with a filter for the front panel intakes
Bad points:
Its Aluminium and it resonantes like hell without modificatoin. The supplied case fans resonate with the case near their mounting points. EAR mounts will solve this
Has drirect path for sound from HDD's to escape.
Fan on top panel badly resonates with the perspex panel. EAR mounts and undervolting help this, but do not resolve it entirely. I removed the top panel and taped the edges.
Filter is time consuming to get to
Good points:
Excellent case fans supplied. They need undervolting, but equal Real Silent Nexus case fans.
Seems to have the potential for good ventilation if fan grills removed.
Perpex panels are well integrated with the case
Comes with a filter for the front panel intakes
Bad points:
Its Aluminium and it resonantes like hell without modificatoin. The supplied case fans resonate with the case near their mounting points. EAR mounts will solve this
Has drirect path for sound from HDD's to escape.
Fan on top panel badly resonates with the perspex panel. EAR mounts and undervolting help this, but do not resolve it entirely. I removed the top panel and taped the edges.
Filter is time consuming to get to
Nice list of recommendations, and very good reviews too. Unfortunately though we can't get many of those cases in little old New Zealand, except the Antec Sonata (VERY expensive here, over NZ$300 or ~US$190), Chenbro Gaming bomb (ugly and not exactly cheap), and the Antec SLK3700AMB (no BQE ). Currently I have a Chieftec Dragon, great solid case but the unrestrictive front lets out all the hdd noise.
Even with the short supply I did stumble accross a quiet case a while ago, and that was an Aopen H600 series case, the H600B. While it doesn't have any quiet specific features it is well made and solid, although still no Chieftec. The included psu is a rebranded Forton 300W (model FSP-300), which is very quiet and quite powerful for a 300W. The single included case fan is a thermister controlled 80mm which is pretty quiet at 12V and plugs in to the motherboard.
One of its strongest featues (imo) is the lack of a front grill. This case is designed to take in airflow from holes in the front of the side panels, and a small intake underneath the front. This keeps the hdd noise down while still cooling them quite well. The top panel is removable by screws, handy if you want to paint or mod it in some way.
The main negative would be the HIGHLY restrictive fan grills, it almost looks like they just punched a few holes as an after thought. Cutting them out was one of the first things I did. Another negative is the fact that all the fan holes are 80mm. 120 or even 92mm fans would have been nice.
More info here.
I have no idea how many places worldwide stock this case, I just thought this might help some of us down under.
Thankyou MikeC for providing such a great site!
Even with the short supply I did stumble accross a quiet case a while ago, and that was an Aopen H600 series case, the H600B. While it doesn't have any quiet specific features it is well made and solid, although still no Chieftec. The included psu is a rebranded Forton 300W (model FSP-300), which is very quiet and quite powerful for a 300W. The single included case fan is a thermister controlled 80mm which is pretty quiet at 12V and plugs in to the motherboard.
One of its strongest featues (imo) is the lack of a front grill. This case is designed to take in airflow from holes in the front of the side panels, and a small intake underneath the front. This keeps the hdd noise down while still cooling them quite well. The top panel is removable by screws, handy if you want to paint or mod it in some way.
The main negative would be the HIGHLY restrictive fan grills, it almost looks like they just punched a few holes as an after thought. Cutting them out was one of the first things I did. Another negative is the fact that all the fan holes are 80mm. 120 or even 92mm fans would have been nice.
More info here.
I have no idea how many places worldwide stock this case, I just thought this might help some of us down under.
Thankyou MikeC for providing such a great site!
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
The Aria is unique in that it is the only non-barebones SFF case. Not shure how we could deal with it. How it compares with other SFF depends a lot on your particular system setup.
IIRC, the Shuttle Zen is quieter, and the AOpen box I reviewed is probably quieter -- hard to say without having exactly the same components in them. Also the best barebones SFF have the advantage of total integration -- ie, the CPU cooling system, the PSU, the case: They are all designed as part of one system.
The mid-tower cases on the Recommended Cases list are quieter. They have the advantage of better airflow, greater air volume, more room for bigger HS, etc.
IIRC, the Shuttle Zen is quieter, and the AOpen box I reviewed is probably quieter -- hard to say without having exactly the same components in them. Also the best barebones SFF have the advantage of total integration -- ie, the CPU cooling system, the PSU, the case: They are all designed as part of one system.
The mid-tower cases on the Recommended Cases list are quieter. They have the advantage of better airflow, greater air volume, more room for bigger HS, etc.
-
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:59 am
Re: New Egg is all out of stock on the black models.. :-(
I used to buy tons of these cases, at least until I found out about the Antec SLK3700...NeilBlanchard wrote:Hello:
The price certainly makes them *very* attractive! However, New Egg is currently totally sold out of *all* the black versions! That must tell you something...what do the addtional letters in the model number mean? Some units seem to only have USB front ports, while others add audio and some also have Firewire.
One other positive point that was pointed out to me by someone who has built 3-4 systems with these: the motherboard supports are pressed into the case, and they are nice smooth domes. Very little chance of damaging the back of the mobo, and very easy!
If only it had 120mm fans and looked a little better...
It's very trivial to modify the front case fan area to take a 120mm. What I've done with all the cases I've had is to cut open the grill and install a washable air filter on the front fan (left it at 80mm). I personally think the best mods would be to go with 92mm fans on the front and back, installing a filter on the front fan.
And I've always bought the model with a fan side arm on it which already includes a filter.
Things get dusty REAL fast in colorado.
FYI, the Fong Kai is almost exactly the case used for Hewlett Packard's xw8000 workstation. The case used is also made by Fong Kai, but is pretty much the same thing. A few differences, it's got 4 bays for hard drives as well as being able to mount a 5th drive on the bottom of the case - the screws go in from underneath. They only have 2 available 5 1/4 drive bays, and the floppy drive is actually in the 3rd drive bay, then the hard drive area extends into where the 3 1/2 floppy drive is in this case. It's hard to tell in the picture if it has screw holes, but the heatsinks actually screw into the reinforcing plate. I'm not sure about the dimensions, but I'd bet that they're the same case with a slight modification, a different bezel and paint job. All the tool-less features are there as well. The only thing we need a torq driver for is to install the heatsinks.MikeC wrote:oops -- forgot the Fong Kai! It was left off my mistake -- to be corrected in the next few hours.
EDIT: Fong Kai added.
I have to say I love working with the HP case, and I'm seriously considering one of these consumer-ized models, although they are rather expensive. The cases have to be good for the workstations, unlike most retail cases, because the customers pay for the quality and some will even refuse delivery if things aren't perfect.
Edit: Just looked closer a the website and there's a model FK-343 with 4 hard drive bays and 2 optical. So I'm guessing that's what we use for the xw8000 systems, just with a different bezel and paint job. Man it's tempting... heh
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 7681
- Joined: Mon Dec 09, 2002 7:11 pm
- Location: Maynard, MA, Eaarth
- Contact:
Another edit is still needed...
Hello Mike:
There is still a typo/brain fart on the Recommended Cases list: it should be "Yeong Yang" -- not Ying Yang...
There is still a typo/brain fart on the Recommended Cases list: it should be "Yeong Yang" -- not Ying Yang...
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
[Many weeks after Tom's post...] Tom, thanks for the Kudos.
The article has been updated again, btw.
The article has been updated again, btw.
Last edited by MikeC on Mon Jan 24, 2005 12:32 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2005 5:09 pm
- Location: Vancouver
- Contact:
P180 Rating?
So, now there are 2 reviews of the Antec P180, I am sure we are all wondering whether it will make it onto the recomended cases list.
(Or, to put it another way, the listing for the P180 should include links to the 2 reviews, even if it is too soon to tell what rating to give it.)
Thanks
(Or, to put it another way, the listing for the P180 should include links to the 2 reviews, even if it is too soon to tell what rating to give it.)
Thanks