Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Just wanted to say that Xbit tested a very nice totally silent system. Take a look at the CPU cooler, it's mind bogling huge...
Review link
Review link
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
On their heat test with the fanless heatsink, it looks like the CPU is throttling? I'm not sure why but the temperature drops signficantly several times. It's not normal behavior.
An interesting concept, but ultimately it's a waste of money when silent fans are so much more effective, cheaper, and (still) silent.
An interesting concept, but ultimately it's a waste of money when silent fans are so much more effective, cheaper, and (still) silent.
-
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Sat May 21, 2011 11:08 am
- Location: Zagreb, Croatia
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
You saw something wrong there, or didn't follow the article correctly...
This diagram on this page shows how this NoFen set works with Intel Core i5 2500K, 95W TDP. As you can see, there is no throttling whatsoever, and maximum CPU temperature is 52 degrees celsius, which is an excellent result.
Now, in this diagram on this page, which you are referring to, the CPU being cooled is Intel Core i7-980X Extreme Edition, which is dissipating 130W TDP, and NoFen clearly stated that their CR-100A passive CPU cooler can cool CPUs up to 100W TDP (they even put '100' in the name). So, this is pushing-beyond-limits kind of test which is not a normal usage case for this 'Set A40' anyway.
And no-fan is just no-fan! Period. They can build evermore perfect fans but they will always: vibrate, make noise, collect dust, deteriorate, and be an ultimate single point of failure.
This diagram on this page shows how this NoFen set works with Intel Core i5 2500K, 95W TDP. As you can see, there is no throttling whatsoever, and maximum CPU temperature is 52 degrees celsius, which is an excellent result.
Now, in this diagram on this page, which you are referring to, the CPU being cooled is Intel Core i7-980X Extreme Edition, which is dissipating 130W TDP, and NoFen clearly stated that their CR-100A passive CPU cooler can cool CPUs up to 100W TDP (they even put '100' in the name). So, this is pushing-beyond-limits kind of test which is not a normal usage case for this 'Set A40' anyway.
And no-fan is just no-fan! Period. They can build evermore perfect fans but they will always: vibrate, make noise, collect dust, deteriorate, and be an ultimate single point of failure.
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
This thing is just stupid. $400 worth of stupid.
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Yes it's too expensive. I can't buy it but it looks silent.
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Isn't the HS itself only $100~?Moogles wrote:This thing is just stupid. $400 worth of stupid.
-
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Tue Feb 14, 2012 12:51 pm
- Location: Södertälje, Sweden
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Hi all, I think this is a breakthrough - a cooler able to passively cool even a hot six core CPU at "full bore" - I am impressed and considering to buy one. However, one remark in the xbitslab review (post #1 ) surprised me a lot:.."...numerous fins made of 2mm aluminum wire...".... ...wow, could it be that simple..?! and if true I fully agree that the price is a bit too high. Anyone out there who knows more..?
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Well, fins made of aluminum are fine. A number of HSFs are simply aluminum with a copper heat pipe inside. The size of this HSF is what sets it apart.canardlover wrote:Hi all, I think this is a breakthrough - a cooler able to passively cool even a hot six core CPU at "full bore" - I am impressed and considering to buy one. However, one remark in the xbitslab review (post #1 ) surprised me a lot:.."...numerous fins made of 2mm aluminum wire...".... ...wow, could it be that simple..?! and if true I fully agree that the price is a bit too high. Anyone out there who knows more..?
As for more info, it's not that fancy, it's just a huge HSF with a lot of surface area on small fins. I'm also wanting to buy one but availability is only Europe and Asia for now. Shipping to NA would cost a lot I think.
-
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Tue Feb 14, 2012 12:51 pm
- Location: Södertälje, Sweden
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Lsv, I am still NOT convinced since Nofan use the term "ice pipes" to describe the cooler principle. Where are they..?? ..
My immediate thought as a chemist would be they are rather tubes filled with a substance having a suitable melting point. Heat of fusion/melting can be rather impressive if you pick the right substance. But that is just a guess and the cooler is a bit too expensive to buy one and cut it apart.....
My immediate thought as a chemist would be they are rather tubes filled with a substance having a suitable melting point. Heat of fusion/melting can be rather impressive if you pick the right substance. But that is just a guess and the cooler is a bit too expensive to buy one and cut it apart.....
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
Re: Nofen Set A40 Fanless System Review
Someone email them and get them to send me a sample for review.