Silent PC with No Moving Parts
It might not be quite as well suited to running tests, but you can get miniITX boards with mobile chipsets that take socket M mobile processors.
I've got an MSI Fuzzy 945GM2 with a core solo and a compact flash card as hard drive - power consumption is right about 24 watts. I've had it running as my router and it's perfectly stable, it's telling me 118 days uptime, and the CPU heatsink never gets more than lukewarm (this is a Scythe Ninja 2 - way more than necessary, and it works fine despite having fins horizontal to the ground).
The only bits that really get warm at all are the little north and south bridge heatsinks and they never get to the point where I can't put my finger on them and leave it there. And remember - mobile parts are made to be able to run at higher temperatures anyway, so the whole deal works really well.
It's another suggestion anyway. Thought I might bring it up as an alternative to the AMD X2, since Core Duos are 31W.
I've got an MSI Fuzzy 945GM2 with a core solo and a compact flash card as hard drive - power consumption is right about 24 watts. I've had it running as my router and it's perfectly stable, it's telling me 118 days uptime, and the CPU heatsink never gets more than lukewarm (this is a Scythe Ninja 2 - way more than necessary, and it works fine despite having fins horizontal to the ground).
The only bits that really get warm at all are the little north and south bridge heatsinks and they never get to the point where I can't put my finger on them and leave it there. And remember - mobile parts are made to be able to run at higher temperatures anyway, so the whole deal works really well.
It's another suggestion anyway. Thought I might bring it up as an alternative to the AMD X2, since Core Duos are 31W.
-
- *Lifetime Patron*
- Posts: 618
- Joined: Mon May 23, 2005 7:05 am
- Location: State College, PA
very nice set up you have there mike, just goes to show how far things have advanced even in the last couple of years.
One Q though - I'm a little surprised by how high you power consumption is. For want of being borish (my rig, blah blah blah), I have an X2 with more ram and a mechanical hdd that idles and loads at ~10-15W lower than that - any idea why the discrepancy? I'm guessing you haven't undervolted, but even so, I can't imagine a single core processor using up that much juice. Just curious, I doubt the extra power draw will bankrupt you any time soon
One Q though - I'm a little surprised by how high you power consumption is. For want of being borish (my rig, blah blah blah), I have an X2 with more ram and a mechanical hdd that idles and loads at ~10-15W lower than that - any idea why the discrepancy? I'm guessing you haven't undervolted, but even so, I can't imagine a single core processor using up that much juice. Just curious, I doubt the extra power draw will bankrupt you any time soon
for a case...
How about an Antec Skeleton with the fan shut off? You'd get good air flow and still have something reasonably solid. Although I have heard that the top fan can limit cpu heat sink height. Might work out.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
Yes, I've been awaiting SSDs for a while. It's the single most exciting that Intel or anyone put out last year -- their X25-M. But these Samsung's are sweet. Not as fast as the Intels; the difference is unnoticeable in general use.mattthemuppet wrote:very nice set up you have there mike, just goes to show how far things have advanced even in the last couple of years.
One Q though - I'm a little surprised by how high you power consumption is. For want of being borish (my rig, blah blah blah), I have an X2 with more ram and a mechanical hdd that idles and loads at ~10-15W lower than that - any idea why the discrepancy? I'm guessing you haven't undervolted, but even so, I can't imagine a single core processor using up that much juice. Just curious, I doubt the extra power draw will bankrupt you any time soon
The main reason your X2 system idles lower is probably because you have CnQ engaged. The 53W I cited was with CnQ off; I've made a quick correction/addtion. It's 41W with it on. At such AC power levels, we're at the declining end of the Silverstone PSU efficiency curve. It never even reaches 80% on this system; it's probably around 75% at full load and probably under 65% at idle.
At idle, the only PSU that would provide any significant power reduction would be the picoPSU with a high efficiency AC/DC power brick. That might save 3-5W -- 10~15%. At maximum load, it would save us maybe 8~9W. But this would mean paying closer attention to sags in the 12V line if multiple drives were connected -- which we do sometimes in drive testing. I'd rather have a robust, flexible system here than one that's a total miser. Since the system isn't on except when testing, little energy is wasted.
Nice short note you dropped us there.
May I ask how you fit your Nightjar into the Antec NSK3480? I have this combo here and didn't manage to squeeze the cables through the little hole that's left due to the extensive length of the power supply. So I had to modify the case a lil bit - widen the whole to the left and cut another one into the right to get the chance of storing all the useless cables behind the mainboard tray.
Anyone else got into this trouble?
Btw: My new computer is gonna look pretty much the same. SSD, Nightjar 450W, 5050e, passively cooled motherboard with a ATI3200 and Display Port to fire my 30" monitor, one or two 120mm fans, a fairly big heat sink (Ninja 2), DVD Drive. I might add a 4750 at some stage but I am not too sure about this idea yet. Could work together with a Musashi and some good fan management (like the Aquaero from Aqua Computer).
May I ask how you fit your Nightjar into the Antec NSK3480? I have this combo here and didn't manage to squeeze the cables through the little hole that's left due to the extensive length of the power supply. So I had to modify the case a lil bit - widen the whole to the left and cut another one into the right to get the chance of storing all the useless cables behind the mainboard tray.
Anyone else got into this trouble?
Btw: My new computer is gonna look pretty much the same. SSD, Nightjar 450W, 5050e, passively cooled motherboard with a ATI3200 and Display Port to fire my 30" monitor, one or two 120mm fans, a fairly big heat sink (Ninja 2), DVD Drive. I might add a 4750 at some stage but I am not too sure about this idea yet. Could work together with a Musashi and some good fan management (like the Aquaero from Aqua Computer).
-
- Posts: 6
- Joined: Fri Apr 10, 2009 2:47 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Cool :)
Looks pretty sweet. I'm actually building a setup that's very similar... using a 35W Athlon X2, with the Orochi. I've managed to fit the whole thing in to a Thermaltake Lanbox HT case - since I'm using a Pico-ATX power supply, the Orochi fits nicely.
The whole thing is completely solid state - using USB instead of SSD though (the large storage kept on a remote Linux server).
The biggest problem I'm facing at this stage is with keeping the northbridge cool... but some newly installed tower coolers should help (fingers crossed).
It's still a work in progress (ie not completed yet), but if you're interested you can see what I've done so far on my blog:
BTW, I hope this post is not considered inappropriate since it links back to my own blog... I've been a big fan of SPCR for quite some time (even mentioned this site in one the above blog posts), and just figured if anyone's interested in this article, then they'd probably like to check out my build too, since it is so similar.
Paul.
The whole thing is completely solid state - using USB instead of SSD though (the large storage kept on a remote Linux server).
The biggest problem I'm facing at this stage is with keeping the northbridge cool... but some newly installed tower coolers should help (fingers crossed).
It's still a work in progress (ie not completed yet), but if you're interested you can see what I've done so far on my blog:
- Completely Solid State 64-bit Dual-Core Media Center PC (original introduction)
- Solid State Media PC build: Part 1 (latest update)
BTW, I hope this post is not considered inappropriate since it links back to my own blog... I've been a big fan of SPCR for quite some time (even mentioned this site in one the above blog posts), and just figured if anyone's interested in this article, then they'd probably like to check out my build too, since it is so similar.
Paul.
-
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2003 4:40 pm
- Location: UK
I use the 300W nightjar PSU in a NSK3480. It's regular ATX size so it fits perfectly
Who needs 450W in a non-gaming rig?
Who needs 450W in a non-gaming rig?
35712 wrote:Nice short note you dropped us there.
May I ask how you fit your Nightjar into the Antec NSK3480? I have this combo here and didn't manage to squeeze the cables through the little hole that's left due to the extensive length of the power supply. So I had to modify the case a lil bit - widen the whole to the left and cut another one into the right to get the chance of storing all the useless cables behind the mainboard tray.
...
Anyone else got into this trouble?
...
-
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2003 4:40 pm
- Location: UK
-
- Posts: 2198
- Joined: Thu Feb 10, 2005 11:20 am
- Location: TN, USA
Thought that looked really great 'till I clicked through and saw that they're $2,250.oakdad wrote:I be lazy.
Just get one of these.
http://www.advantech.com/products/UNO-2 ... MLJCC.aspx
My core solo router that I described above was about $250 (sans enclosure). I think I'll stick with that.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 7681
- Joined: Mon Dec 09, 2002 7:11 pm
- Location: Maynard, MA, Eaarth
- Contact:
-
- *Lifetime Patron*
- Posts: 2269
- Joined: Sun May 21, 2006 9:09 am
- Location: Northern California.
Reduce Reuse Recycle?wayner wrote:Why does the setup described in this article have a floppy?
And since it does have a floppy it does have moving parts so isn't the title inaccurate?
photo's caption from 1st page.
"...There are no moving parts except for the floppy; even that's silent once the Hitachi Feature Tool HDD utility is loaded."
Whos game to try it? sounds promising.NeilBlanchard wrote:
I wonder if the Scythe Mugen 2 would work for this system in a standard tower case?
I know it's not exactly a big issue, but you can actually set up a USB flash drive with a DOS environment. I use one to load the Hitachi tool, as well as Ghost, memtest86+, BIOS flashing tools etc.xan_user wrote:Reduce Reuse Recycle?
photo's caption from 1st page.
"...There are no moving parts except for the floppy; even that's silent once the Hitachi Feature Tool HDD utility is loaded."
To do it use the HP tool from this site:
http://files.extremeoverclocking.com/file.php?f=197
You need some basic DOS files (it prompts you for their location when needed), but you can easily get them by simply making a bootable DOS floppy disk in Windows and using those files.
Not only is it much faster than a floppy disk, you can store a lot more and it is of course completely silent with no moving parts.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
I'm aware of this & the HP tool, used it in the past. But the floppy is not exactly a hardship...MoJo wrote:I know it's not exactly a big issue, but you can actually set up a USB flash drive with a DOS environment. I use one to load the Hitachi tool, as well as Ghost, memtest86+, BIOS flashing tools etc.xan_user wrote:Reduce Reuse Recycle?
photo's caption from 1st page.
"...There are no moving parts except for the floppy; even that's silent once the Hitachi Feature Tool HDD utility is loaded."
To do it use the HP tool from this site:
http://files.extremeoverclocking.com/file.php?f=197
You need some basic DOS files (it prompts you for their location when needed), but you can easily get them by simply making a bootable DOS floppy disk in Windows and using those files.
Not only is it much faster than a floppy disk, you can store a lot more and it is of course completely silent with no moving parts.
-
- *Lifetime Patron*
- Posts: 618
- Joined: Mon May 23, 2005 7:05 am
- Location: State College, PA
ah, okay, that makes a bit more sense. My X2 is actually undervolted using CrystalCPUID (0.825V idle, 1.075V load), which should help a bit, though I seem to remember that you're a little cautious of software undervolting. I do have the occasional problem (usually in v. hot weather, like >30C inside), so I would be hesitant to use it for a work PC like yours. I've looked into a picoPSU several times, but the economics just don't stack up.MikeC wrote: The main reason your X2 system idles lower is probably because you have CnQ engaged. The 53W I cited was with CnQ off; I've made a quick correction/addtion. It's 41W with it on. At such AC power levels, we're at the declining end of the Silverstone PSU efficiency curve. It never even reaches 80% on this system; it's probably around 75% at full load and probably under 65% at idle.
At idle, the only PSU that would provide any significant power reduction would be the picoPSU with a high efficiency AC/DC power brick. That might save 3-5W -- 10~15%. At maximum load, it would save us maybe 8~9W. But this would mean paying closer attention to sags in the 12V line if multiple drives were connected -- which we do sometimes in drive testing. I'd rather have a robust, flexible system here than one that's a total miser. Since the system isn't on except when testing, little energy is wasted.
when the smaller SSDs get a bit more affordable, I'd definitely bite for a system drive - not so much for the noise or power benefit, as my PC's effectively inaudible (especially when my children are awake ), but for the speed
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
huh? How is anything they offer "better?" They claim 0 dba but the stock solutions include a standard heatpipe heatsink for the CPU and an 80gb Seagate HDD.tuleggi wrote:Hi,
actually better solutions for silent PC quite powerful are here:
deltatronic[dot]de/int/pc/index.html
The principle is simple enough, and really cannot be "bettered": Use components with no moving parts for a silent PC.
electronic whine
my brick powering a picopsu whines more under less load. When I turn off the PC, the brick starts to whine and whines even louder a few seconds after I unplug it from the wall...
Re: electronic whine
Aquarium safe silicone is the best solution, but in a pinch hot melt glue can also be used.charonme wrote:my brick powering a picopsu whines more under less load. When I turn off the PC, the brick starts to whine and whines even louder a few seconds after I unplug it from the wall...