[Warning: I'm going to go off on a bit of a rant here. Read it or skip down to where I calm down and get back to the topic at hand - my trying to get Internet access restored to my desktop Windows XP machine so that it can resume folding.]
Charlie, I admire your restraint.
Mutt_n_head, if you have anything constructive to offer I'm all ears.
I'm pretty certain that Charlie didn't just fall off any turnip truck. I believe the advice I have recieved has been sound. Sure, I occasionally wonder where Charlie is coming from, but nearly always I discover later that he was just a step ahead of me. Without his help (and others), I would be in serious trouble.
I'd like to think I'm not a
complete idiot either. I'm new to Linux but have two years of UNIX (True/64) plus a bazillion years of VAX/VMS, albiet as a programmer and not a "systems" guy, so configuring DHCP and DNS servers is new to me, and I don't have a strong networking background so I don't immediately understand a lot of the concepts. But I have "been around" computers (selling them, assembling them, programming them, using them) since the Apple II, I know how to use 'man' and 'info' and
www.google.com, and while I'm asking questions, I am looking for the answers in another window.
I'm NOT saying there isn't a simple solution to this problem, since it's entirely possible it's something really obvious I've simply overlooked. I will suggest that if you have only "seen it done" or "participated in" setting one up, that you should walk a mile in my shoes., i.e. do one yourself, from scratch, then come tell us how easy it was.
[Beginning to mellow a bit here, having blown off a bit o' steam...]
It's fairly safe to say I won't give up before I get "the farm" up and running, not in frustration anyway. The specific issue I am having with my desktop machine is a different story. That machine has been two days now without an Internet connection, and I have tried everything I know how to try. If it was working OK except for that, I'd keep banging away at it because I know it can be fixed. In seven years and quite a few PC's, I have never needed to resort to a "clean install" of Windows to fix a problem. However, in this case, this PC has been 'sick' for quite a long time. It takes forever to boot. It crashes occasionally "for no reason". It has had a bazillion applications installed and uninstalled and just plain deleted with a crowbar. My son runs Kazaa, and downloads all kinds of stuff. Whenever I run Ad-aware, it deletes at least 50 things. If/when I do a clean install, it will be for more reasons than to just fix just one problem.
But this one problem so totally fascinates me (!) that I'd love to find a solution to it, even if I just turn around and do a clean install anyway.
[OK, I'm 90% down off my rant and heading back toward the off-topic topic Charlie and I were working on before I got off onto my rant...]
I don't know that the issue dnsmasq is having with the inverse name resolution is the cause of the problem with pcnut. I'm inclined to say no because even if I open the TCP/IP properties and enter a fixed IP address (so that DHCP isn't used), and point it to the IP address of the D-Link router (bypassing the Linux DNS), it behaves no differently.
I can see, by watching the dnsmasq log, that a domain name like
www.google.com is received from pcnut and resolved to an IP address, and (presumably!) passed back to pcnut, but it's like pcnut never gets the message. It behaves as if its name server is down.
I can transfer files to and from pcnut, browse it from other machines on the LAN, ping it, so I'm comfortable that the network card is working just fine, but if I try to ping
www.google.com from pcnut, it times out.
The following three machines (plus another) are connected to a D-Link 4-port broadband router:
- pcnut, XP Home, Internet access - No
- psc, XP Pro, Internet access - Yes
- fahserv, RedHat 9 Linux, Internet access - Yes
pcnut and psc, other than one being 'Home' and one 'Pro' are otherwise connected and configured the same. Both are connected to the network the same, are running the same browser, have the same TCP/IP configurations, and have similar etc/host files. Both are treated the same in the /etc/dhcpd.conf file. In fact, neither is mentioned by name anywhere on the Linux server. Both get their configurations the same way from DCHP, unless I've overlooked something on the server, which is entirely possible.
But the name server is definitely having some sort if issue with pcnut that it's NOT having with psc, so
something is different, I just haven't been able to figure out what.
[
ON TOPIC]
The Artic Cooling heatsinks arrived today from SVC, so I have everything I need now for one diskless client. The power supplies arrived yesterday. By next week sometime I should have all the parts for 3 "blades".
David
[WHEW!]
[Edited to remove some overly harsh comments
]