I tried both auto and 50% but it doesn't seem like there is any change at all in the fan speed and it's driving me insane to say the least. It's my exhaust fan which is an old Evercool 120mm Metal bodied fan, In theory I really should just swap it out for a 900rpm Scythe but I just don't have the money right now and it looks like where I buy all my parts (Newegg) don't carry Scythe fans anymore

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated! At the point I'm just ready to just pull the fan header and see what the temps look like w/o an exaust fan I'm running anywhere from 34 - 36C right now.