Passive cooling a P4?
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
Passive cooling a P4?
Some of you have probably seen this article.. is it trustworthy??? I cant imagine passive cooling a 2.8ghz p4...
Yeah I think something isn't right. Zalman said it cools up to 3.06 with a 92mm fan at 1300RPM. But they said they had no fans near the processor. Another thing is that they used a Thermaltake powersupply as there only exaust or fan for that matter and also commenting on it being silent. IMO there is a missing piece somewhere.
-
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 11:14 pm
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
So a reviewer of "hardcore gamers" stuff points to a PC that has a 2-fan stock PSU and a barracuda hdd mounted normally, and says it is "absolutely DEAD SILENT". Do you believe it? not me. I can hear any 2-fan PSU from across the room, ditto any normally mounted drive seeking.
But focusing on the issue of whether the Zalman 6500BCU can cool a P4-2.8 fanless, sure, but for how long? I ran that combo with a Panaflo fan at 6-8V and often, that was not enough if the system was on for more than an hour. And my system had well directed low airflow. Also the zalman clips wear, so the temp might be low in the beginning, but give them a couple of weeks with the 1kg weight hanging against them, and it's another story.
In general this article seems kind of misleading.
But focusing on the issue of whether the Zalman 6500BCU can cool a P4-2.8 fanless, sure, but for how long? I ran that combo with a Panaflo fan at 6-8V and often, that was not enough if the system was on for more than an hour. And my system had well directed low airflow. Also the zalman clips wear, so the temp might be low in the beginning, but give them a couple of weeks with the 1kg weight hanging against them, and it's another story.
In general this article seems kind of misleading.
-
- Posts: 376
- Joined: Sun May 04, 2003 4:33 pm
- Location: Athlonville, My Computer
- Contact:
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 12285
- Joined: Sun Aug 11, 2002 3:26 pm
- Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
- Contact:
It's not his meter reading I question but what he hears and what he judges as "dead silent". People have noticed before how often oc sites' perceptions of loud/soft contradict opinions at SPCR (as well as their own perceptions). Not everyone has the same standards. If your normal system has 100+ cfm and related fan noise, then your expectation (psychoacoustically speaking) is very different from someone whose systems have 20 cfm or less. (Most of mine are in this category.)Politik wrote:He says he held the DB meter right next to the PSU exhaust, so presumably it would be much quieter at a more common testing position.
And our standards for quiet are more demanding than any other site or group on the web.
EDITED -- spell check
Last edited by MikeC on Sat May 24, 2003 10:13 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 11:14 pm
Update: Since the article was originally published, we had some people questioning whether 40 dB is truly silent. Well I will admit that our sound level testing may have been flawed in this case. I should not have put the sound meter right up to the power supply like that, but rather 2 or 3 feet away from the PC, as in normal operation.
I tried this originally, but I didn't think I was picking up a reading! That's right, this PC was TOO SILENT, and it threw me off (the sound it put out was not above ambient noise levels, so I couldn't pick it up).
So please take my word for it - this rig is absolutely DEAD SILENT.
-
- Friend of SPCR
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Thu Nov 28, 2002 5:07 pm
- Location: London, UK
Dead silent is a word I would not use lightly. A fan that makes any noise is not silent. So with regards that is the only thing that makes any noise, then it can't be silent.
Some people here have passive computers and don't even use a fan and they don't refer to their computer as being dead silent. A HD makes noise even when not seeking to our ears! and is probably the noisiest component when your system is quiet enough.
So your suggestion it is dead silent is your perception of the level of quietness. Decouple your Barracuda (hold it in your hand) and we still don't call it dead silent so how you come with this statement is astonishing.
Some people here have passive computers and don't even use a fan and they don't refer to their computer as being dead silent. A HD makes noise even when not seeking to our ears! and is probably the noisiest component when your system is quiet enough.
So your suggestion it is dead silent is your perception of the level of quietness. Decouple your Barracuda (hold it in your hand) and we still don't call it dead silent so how you come with this statement is astonishing.
I'm just curious, how do you know so much about this system? Do you know this guy or something?skinnypupp wrote:Trust me, the single 80mm fan in the Thermaltake PSU is the only thing that generates any sort of noise in that system, and it is truly "dead silent". You don't have to take my word for it though...
-
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 11:14 pm
To me, "Dead Silent" means "you can't hear a damn thing when you're in the same room as the PC".
It doesn't mean "you can hear the hard drive whining when you take it out and put it to your ear while it's seeking".
Obviously I'm not as fanatic as the people in a forum dedicated to silent computing. Neither are the rest of the people on the internet who do not read this site.
It doesn't mean "you can hear the hard drive whining when you take it out and put it to your ear while it's seeking".
Obviously I'm not as fanatic as the people in a forum dedicated to silent computing. Neither are the rest of the people on the internet who do not read this site.
DittoPolitik wrote:I'm just curious, how do you know so much about this system? Do you know this guy or something?skinnypupp wrote:Trust me, the single 80mm fan in the Thermaltake PSU is the only thing that generates any sort of noise in that system, and it is truly "dead silent". You don't have to take my word for it though...