speccing a Core 2 Duo rig, trying to avoid P180
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
speccing a Core 2 Duo rig, trying to avoid P180
Current setup: Antec P180, passively cooled 3.2GHz Northwood (Ninja Scythe), passively cooled Geforce 6800 vanilla, 5 hard drives (one is a raptor), Antec 550W true power PSU, 5 120MM case fans, I think 2 are Nexus 120mm. All fans on low setting. This is a *really* quiet setup. I want to remain this quiet with my new system. But I'd like to get a nicer looking case than the P180.
I'm going to Puget Systems for the custom build, to make sure I get a *quiet* system (they will do the modding). Yes, I know this is more expensive than building it myself. Use: light gaming (I'd like to try some of the new ones), HTPC, video and music encoding (divx/itunes), and all your basic music/internet/movie/office stuff. I also like to multitask, such as watch a dvd while ripping a CD into iTunes and unzipping a file and moving a bunch of files around.
Parts:
Asus P5WDH Deluxe
Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 (2.40 GHz, FSB1066, 4 MB L2)
Thermalright XP-120 Heatsink w/ 120mm Scythe Fan (puget undvolts the scythe fans)
Corsair XMS TWIN2X2048-6400C4 EPP DDR2-800 2x1024MB
Asus EN7900GT 256MB w/ Artic Cooling VGA Cooler - NV Silencer 5 Rev. 3
Seasonic S12 Series 500W Power Supply
Western Digital SATA Raptor 150GB w/ Smart Drive 2002C Enclosure
Creative X-Fi XtremeMusic
2x optical drives
Also, I have to fit 4 hard drives for data storage somewhere. If it's in a NAS, so be it, but getting them into the case would be great.
I was HOPING that I could get away with a Silverstone TJ04 (2x 120mm undervolted scythes) with Puget doing a bunch of AcoustiPack Standard Acoustic Composite Sheets modding. And still stay as quiet as my current system.
But, if I have to, I'll go with a black Antec P180. (I like the way it looks better than the standard one.) (I'm also trying to avoid cases that are *larger* than the P180.)
Any thoughts? I've seen tons of cases over the past few days, and I just can't find one I like.
Thanks!
I'm going to Puget Systems for the custom build, to make sure I get a *quiet* system (they will do the modding). Yes, I know this is more expensive than building it myself. Use: light gaming (I'd like to try some of the new ones), HTPC, video and music encoding (divx/itunes), and all your basic music/internet/movie/office stuff. I also like to multitask, such as watch a dvd while ripping a CD into iTunes and unzipping a file and moving a bunch of files around.
Parts:
Asus P5WDH Deluxe
Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 (2.40 GHz, FSB1066, 4 MB L2)
Thermalright XP-120 Heatsink w/ 120mm Scythe Fan (puget undvolts the scythe fans)
Corsair XMS TWIN2X2048-6400C4 EPP DDR2-800 2x1024MB
Asus EN7900GT 256MB w/ Artic Cooling VGA Cooler - NV Silencer 5 Rev. 3
Seasonic S12 Series 500W Power Supply
Western Digital SATA Raptor 150GB w/ Smart Drive 2002C Enclosure
Creative X-Fi XtremeMusic
2x optical drives
Also, I have to fit 4 hard drives for data storage somewhere. If it's in a NAS, so be it, but getting them into the case would be great.
I was HOPING that I could get away with a Silverstone TJ04 (2x 120mm undervolted scythes) with Puget doing a bunch of AcoustiPack Standard Acoustic Composite Sheets modding. And still stay as quiet as my current system.
But, if I have to, I'll go with a black Antec P180. (I like the way it looks better than the standard one.) (I'm also trying to avoid cases that are *larger* than the P180.)
Any thoughts? I've seen tons of cases over the past few days, and I just can't find one I like.
Thanks!
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Thu Jun 29, 2006 7:54 am
man, that's a tall order. pretty picky, eh?
Check out the Lian Li V1100 - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.a ... 6811112073
Pricy? yep, but it is a nice lookin case and, by all accounts, a good one.
Check out the Lian Li V1100 - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.a ... 6811112073
Pricy? yep, but it is a nice lookin case and, by all accounts, a good one.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
Picky? You have no idea...
I keep my computer on 24/7, do a lot with it, and live (and sleep) in a studio apartment... c'est la vie, eh?
That Lian-Li won't work, it mounts the motherboard upside down, which screws with the heatpipe/heatsink setup on the ASUS mobo that cools the northbridge. Yeah, throwing in that whole "the mobo must be mounted rightside UP" is throwing an additional monkeywrench in the works.
But based on what I've read in these forums about the TJ04, it's steel body will help a lot, and I think if Puget does some modding with the AcoustiPack Standard Acoustic Composite Sheets and undervolted scythe fans, it might just work...
I'd just hate to be wrong after spending all this money, as I'd have to spend even more to fix it...
I keep my computer on 24/7, do a lot with it, and live (and sleep) in a studio apartment... c'est la vie, eh?
That Lian-Li won't work, it mounts the motherboard upside down, which screws with the heatpipe/heatsink setup on the ASUS mobo that cools the northbridge. Yeah, throwing in that whole "the mobo must be mounted rightside UP" is throwing an additional monkeywrench in the works.
But based on what I've read in these forums about the TJ04, it's steel body will help a lot, and I think if Puget does some modding with the AcoustiPack Standard Acoustic Composite Sheets and undervolted scythe fans, it might just work...
I'd just hate to be wrong after spending all this money, as I'd have to spend even more to fix it...
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
Picky strikes again! I love the black aluminium front panel of the Silverstone cases.
Also, the Solo (and the P150) only have 92mm fan mounts in the front. I have yet to meet a 92mm fan that is quiet while still delivering adequate airflow. The Nexus 120mm, on the other hand...
Also, I have dual optical drives, and mounting the Smart Drive enclosure for the raptor right under an optical drive really cuts down on airflow (the Smart Drive dampens sound as well as improving cooling.)
Thanks for all the suggestions so far!
Also, the Solo (and the P150) only have 92mm fan mounts in the front. I have yet to meet a 92mm fan that is quiet while still delivering adequate airflow. The Nexus 120mm, on the other hand...
Also, I have dual optical drives, and mounting the Smart Drive enclosure for the raptor right under an optical drive really cuts down on airflow (the Smart Drive dampens sound as well as improving cooling.)
Thanks for all the suggestions so far!
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
A little more digging turned up the fact that the TJ04 has a very restricted flow of air for the front 120mm intake fan. Not so good.
I'm thinking it's going to have to be the black P180. I currently have an "original" P180, and I know for a fact that it can *quietly* cool a P4 Northwood 3.2GHz, a Geforce 6800, 4x IDE hard drives, a 550W antec truepower, AND a raptor sata drive.
And I suppose that going with what you know is a sure way to do it right the first time around. I can always see what cases come out in the future...
The stacker is a little too large for my tastes - even larger than the P180, which is what I'm trying to avoid.
Thanks for all the suggestions so far!
I'm thinking it's going to have to be the black P180. I currently have an "original" P180, and I know for a fact that it can *quietly* cool a P4 Northwood 3.2GHz, a Geforce 6800, 4x IDE hard drives, a 550W antec truepower, AND a raptor sata drive.
And I suppose that going with what you know is a sure way to do it right the first time around. I can always see what cases come out in the future...
The stacker is a little too large for my tastes - even larger than the P180, which is what I'm trying to avoid.
What do you do now?A while ago I was thinking like you, going with all 120mm fans.
Thanks for all the suggestions so far!
As I don't like the inverted nature of the P180 my choices are pretty much limited to the P150 for good silencing. Even a 92mm fan will generate enough airflow for the drives and at 5-6V it will be near silent.grepcomputers wrote:What do you do now?
I'm also counting on a positive sucking over the drives from a HIS digital iceQ card (I think blowing out the hot air instead of recirculating it is a very good idea).
I'll just have to live with it.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
Cables on my PSU would be too short (early S12 version) and reading the forums here, neatness seems to be a problem. Plus I don't think the passive nb cooler on the P5WDH Deluxe (I'm getting that board too) works optimally inverted like that. You will probably get away with it, since the XP-120s downward blowing will give airflow over the heatsink (though I'd look carefully at the nb, it will be warmer inverted). I want a ninja, so an inverted passive board goes right out, it will fry.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon Jul 24, 2006 9:54 am
The Antec P180 doesn't invert the motherboard. Or do you mean inverted airflow? Surely that could be fixed by having the top and the rear fans exhaust (both at low RPM so as to not overpower the intake). And I believe Antec's default setup is to have the top and the rear as exhaust...
Admittedly, when I used a Ninja Scythe to passively cool my Northwood 3.2GHz, I inverted the top fan so it blows cold air down through the ninja and then out the back, but there's no northbridge cooling problem on an Intel 875 board...
Admittedly, when I used a Ninja Scythe to passively cool my Northwood 3.2GHz, I inverted the top fan so it blows cold air down through the ninja and then out the back, but there's no northbridge cooling problem on an Intel 875 board...
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2005 5:30 am
- Contact: