I cannot get Asus Q-Fan to work
Moderators: NeilBlanchard, Ralf Hutter, sthayashi, Lawrence Lee
I cannot get Asus Q-Fan to work
I have enabled Q-Fan in BIOS, like you can see in the screen shot below. It still does not seem to do anything. I have tried other settings as well and of course saved the settings and restarted several times in the process.
As I understand it, if the CPU temp is lower than the target temperature, the fan will run at a slower speed based on the fan ratio. But no matter what settings I try, all I see is 45 degrees and 2600 rpm fan speed. What am I doing wrong?
The mobo is an Asus P5B-MX micro-atx and the cpu a celeron 420 with a stock cooler. It might be hard to see on this pic, but the fan is connected to the right spot.
As I understand it, if the CPU temp is lower than the target temperature, the fan will run at a slower speed based on the fan ratio. But no matter what settings I try, all I see is 45 degrees and 2600 rpm fan speed. What am I doing wrong?
The mobo is an Asus P5B-MX micro-atx and the cpu a celeron 420 with a stock cooler. It might be hard to see on this pic, but the fan is connected to the right spot.
Thanks for the tip. I updated to the newest bios -version 0506 I think- but it still doesn't work. Something is weird though, the version number in the menu is still the same as in the screen shot above, v2.58. But the first bios screen says version 0506. Perhaps there's more than one program involved?
Anyway, I guess I'll have to do without q-fan.
Anyway, I guess I'll have to do without q-fan.
-
- Posts: 2198
- Joined: Thu Feb 10, 2005 11:20 am
- Location: TN, USA
I do have the asus p5w-dh deluxe. That Q-Fan works, but all it does is lowering the fan rpm to a predefined setting high, medium or low. It is NOT adaptive. The old asus q-fan's were adaptive. The newer versions are not, at least that is what I have read on the asus website. I didn't like it, but that is how it is ; at least with my motherboard.
I removed the motherboard temporarily, to remove the hd rack. When I get it back together I'll try to enable the chassis fan. Since I'll replace the antec case fan (with a 4-pin molex) for a nexus, I'll actually have a 3-pin connector to plug in and get a reading from. Maybe that will help.
I did try with a number of settings, including the "maximum". I think that was 60 something degrees and a ratio of 20%. Although I only left the computer on for about 20 minutes, but I noticed no difference.
Oh, by the way, when is q-fan supposed to start working? Do I need to actually boot an os? Stupid question maybe, but maybe the bios setup is in some kind of fail safe mode with all the fans on max speed..?
sjoukew, does your setup menu look the same as mine, or is it another version?
I did try with a number of settings, including the "maximum". I think that was 60 something degrees and a ratio of 20%. Although I only left the computer on for about 20 minutes, but I noticed no difference.
Oh, by the way, when is q-fan supposed to start working? Do I need to actually boot an os? Stupid question maybe, but maybe the bios setup is in some kind of fail safe mode with all the fans on max speed..?
sjoukew, does your setup menu look the same as mine, or is it another version?
on my P5K-SE with Intel Core 2 cpu:
fan control of the processor works fine (between 800 - 880 rpm, never needed more than that). If I disable Qfan control, fan get much louder. I have different profiles that I can choose from: silent/perfomance/auto. No temperature.
fan control of the case: didn't work in the beginning (I couldn't monitor the current fan speed, speed was N/A rpm). In fact, my fan was so slow (< 600 rpm, noctua fan with ULNA resistor), that it couldn't measure it. without ULNA, I got 1200 rpm at first, but after setting Qfan to 'auto' and rebooting (needed reboot to apply the Qfan settings from the BIOS), the fan was regulated. Fan now runs between 800 and 1200 rpm. It can even be 600 with LNA resistor (smaller resistor than ULNA).
If plugging a fan into the PWR fan connector, I can monitor the speed, but I can't set any profile or dynamic behaviour into the BIOS, so it is fixed speed.
best regards.
fan control of the processor works fine (between 800 - 880 rpm, never needed more than that). If I disable Qfan control, fan get much louder. I have different profiles that I can choose from: silent/perfomance/auto. No temperature.
fan control of the case: didn't work in the beginning (I couldn't monitor the current fan speed, speed was N/A rpm). In fact, my fan was so slow (< 600 rpm, noctua fan with ULNA resistor), that it couldn't measure it. without ULNA, I got 1200 rpm at first, but after setting Qfan to 'auto' and rebooting (needed reboot to apply the Qfan settings from the BIOS), the fan was regulated. Fan now runs between 800 and 1200 rpm. It can even be 600 with LNA resistor (smaller resistor than ULNA).
If plugging a fan into the PWR fan connector, I can monitor the speed, but I can't set any profile or dynamic behaviour into the BIOS, so it is fixed speed.
best regards.
Hi MoJo,
Have you applied changed (save BIOS and reboot) to check it doesn't work (my changes doesn't apply realtime in the BIOS, only affect the result after reboot) ?
Are you sure the fan is connected to the motherboard, on a controllable fan pin ? (I can only control speed on 2 of my 3 fan connectors : chassis & cpu, not on the power fan).
Can you read/monitor in the BIOS the speed of the fan ?
best regards
Have you applied changed (save BIOS and reboot) to check it doesn't work (my changes doesn't apply realtime in the BIOS, only affect the result after reboot) ?
Are you sure the fan is connected to the motherboard, on a controllable fan pin ? (I can only control speed on 2 of my 3 fan connectors : chassis & cpu, not on the power fan).
Can you read/monitor in the BIOS the speed of the fan ?
best regards
bp, I did do that, yes. I don't think it's a problem with Qfan itself though, but rather the temperature sensor on the mobo.
I have a QX6700. When Coretemp says one core has hit 67C, the mobo CPU temp sensor says 40C. I think Qfan is reading from the mobo sensor so it never changes the fan speed. It always seems to be on full anyway, and both BIOS and the Asus software allow you to set with Qfan or 60-100% speed, which has no effect.
The chassis and optional fan headers can be controlled manually and they work, just not the CPU one.
I have a QX6700. When Coretemp says one core has hit 67C, the mobo CPU temp sensor says 40C. I think Qfan is reading from the mobo sensor so it never changes the fan speed. It always seems to be on full anyway, and both BIOS and the Asus software allow you to set with Qfan or 60-100% speed, which has no effect.
The chassis and optional fan headers can be controlled manually and they work, just not the CPU one.